Thursday, February 14, 2013

A Jargon-Free Property Rights Update for Forest Landowners

Thanks to the Southeastern Wood Producers Association for inviting me to give its membership a "Forestry and Property Rights Legal Update" in the latest edition of its newsletter, Out of the Woods. It's excerpted below:

Forestry and Property Rights Legal Update

In recent months, there have been several legal developments that property owners and those involved in forestry should know about. Having some familiarity with these legal issues can be an important service to the landowners that members of this Association work with.

You’ve probably heard about the forest roads lawsuit, Decker v. NEDC, argued before the U.S. Supreme Court in early December. At stake is whether logging roads and ditches need federal stormwater permits. Since the 1970s, EPA has agreed they do not with its “Silvicultural Rule.” When environmentalists sued in Oregon, a federal court ruled that EPA was incorrect. Last year, Congress blocked EPA from developing the new permit while the case was on appeal.

The case before the Supreme Court looked strong. EPA, however, complicated things by issuing a new rule intended to replace the faulty Silvicultural Rule on the eve of the case being heard. While the new rule helps the forestry community by generally not requiring permits for logging roads and ditches, the Supreme Court seemed concerned about this new development. The Supreme Court should rule by July. For now, it has asked the parties for further information about EPA’s new rule. The only real solution here is congressional action, so talk to your U.S. representative and senators about this issue.

Two important property rights cases have not been in the news quite as much. One case, Koontz v. St. Johns River Water Management District, questions bargaining practices that governments use for land-related permits. There, the government agreed to issue a permit to fill wetlands if the landowner paid to improve government culverts miles away. The landowner refused and sued when the government denied the permit. The Florida Supreme Court said the landowner could only challenge the unreasonable permit demand after giving in to it.

The outcome of Koontz will be important to all landowners—even average homeowners and agricultural landowners. The growth in government at all levels means that every landowner in the country is now subject to a complex permitting regime. Imagine a local government that requires you to buy $25,000 in new library books in order to get a permit to build a new deck. Or a state agency that requires a timberlands owner in the Panhandle to build a nature walk in South Florida to get a permit to build a logging road. The Supreme Court is being asked to decide how far these outrageous requests can go. I was fortunate to be involved in this case. I watched the oral arguments in Washington, D.C. in January and am cautiously optimistic that the Justices will support the landowner.

The other recent property rights case before the Supreme Court has already been decided—and it was a big win for landowners and forestry. In Arkansas Game and Fish Commission v. United States, the Supreme Court held that a landowner could be compensated where the federal government’s temporary flooding of the property destroyed millions of dollars of standing timber.

From the beginning of the Republic, governments have tried to get out of paying compensation for property they take by arguing it was for the public good. The Supreme Court once again rejected this argument. The Constitution, it said, requires the government to pay landowners for damages to property, no matter whether the government had a good reason for its actions or not.

We must be our own advocates for property rights and the sound environmental practices used in forestry. As these cases illustrate, we must remain diligent in working to protect our property rights and livelihoods. The next time you talk to a landowner, tell them about these recent developments. Remind them about the legal struggles that our industry faced and is still facing out West because our laws prioritize the Northern Spotted Owl above people. It could happen here if we are not mindful.

Jacob T. Cremer is an attorney at Bricklemyer Smolker, P.A., in Tampa. His practice focuses on property rights, environmental, and land use law. He grew up in a family that has been involved in forestry in Florida for many generations. Follow the developments on these cases and others at his blog, The Florida Land Environment.

Monday, February 11, 2013

The Constitutional Issues at Stake in Koontz, Simplified

Many thanks to the newsletter for the Constitutional Law Committee of the American Bar Association's Section of Environment, Energy, and Resources, which recently published my article about Koontz v. St Johns River Water Management District, No. 11-1447 (argued Jan. 15, 2012). I sought to provide another plain-language summary of the case, although more to a legal audience than my last summary. Here it is:

U.S. Supreme Court Hears Important Florida Exactions Case

These days, Florida is a hotbed of property rights litigation. Three years ago, Florida was defending its beach renourishment program before the U.S. Supreme Court. Stop the Beach Renourishment, Inc. v. Fla. Dep't of Envtl. Prot., 130 S. Ct. 2592 (2010). That case broke new ground when a plurality of justices acknowledged that a court can take property, just as the legislative and executive branches can.

Now that the U.S. Supreme Court has heard Koontz v. St. Johns River Water Management District, No. 11-1447 (cert. granted Oct. 5, 2012, argued Jan. 15, 2013), environmental attorneys, constitutional scholars, and land use planners are wondering if Florida will again be on the forefront of takings law. This could be the most important decision in the world of environmental and land use permitting in years. It could draw into question common bargaining practices by governments when requesting conditions in exchange for development permits.

In the development approval process, governments commonly require a dedication of real property to mitigate adverse impacts. But what if the request is for cash or for services? What if the request is unreasonable, and the landowner cannot use the property?

Background

The Takings Clause of the Fifth Amendment to the U.S. Constitution ensures that private property cannot “be taken for public use, without just compensation.” The Takings Clause was intended to bar government from forcing individuals from bearing public burdens alone. Lingle v. Chevron U.S.A. Inc., 544 U.S. 528, 548 (2005). Early cases focused on physical invasions of property. As the regulatory state grew in the twentieth century, the U.S. Supreme Court began to recognize that government regulation of private property can sometimes be so onerous that it is tantamount to the government appropriating the property. Id. An exaction is a government requirement to donate something in exchange for the right to develop property. Oftentimes, this is a requirement to dedicate real property. Generally, the government cannot force landowners to give up the right to exclude others from property in return for the ability to develop it. It can, however, require mitigation of adverse development impacts. The U.S. Supreme Court has given some limited guidance on how to determine whether an exaction passes constitutional muster:
  1. There must be an “essential nexus” between the exaction and the interest that the exaction is advancing. Nollan v. Cal. Coastal Com., 483 U.S. 825, 837 (1987).
  2. There must be a “rough proportionality” in both nature and extent between the exaction and the impact of the proposed development. Dolan v. Tigard, 512 U.S. 374, 391 (2005).
Nollan and Dolan both addressed exactions of easements for public access. The U.S. Supreme Court left open whether the Nollan-Dolan test applied to exactions not involving real property, such as exactions for money or other personal property. Courts have differed on this question, leading to confusion among landowners, planners, regulators, and government officials.

The Koontz Cases

In St. Johns River Water Management District v. Koontz, 77 So. 3d 1220 (Fla. 2011), the Florida Supreme Court declined to recognize an exaction under U.S. Supreme Court precedent. Koontz  had owned his property since 1972. He been trying to develop his property since 1994, when he had applied to the District for a permit to develop his property. All but 1.4 acres of the 14.2-acre property were in a Riparian Habitat Protection Zone. Koontz only wanted to develop 3.7 acres of the property, but he would have to fill 3.4 acres of wetlands to do so.

The District agreed to grant the permit on two conditions. First, the District required that Koontz deed the remainder of his property into a conservation area, which he agreed to do. Second, the District required that Koontz perform offsite mitigation several miles by replacing culverts and plugging drainage canals on District-owned properties seven miles from his property, which Koontz refused.

When the District then denied the permit, Koontz sued in state court, arguing that the District’s offsite mitigation condition was an unconstitutional exaction because it violated the Nollan-Dolan test. The case bounced around between the trial court and the intermediate appellate court for years, producing some important takings jurisprudence in Florida. Ultimately, the trial court found that the District had taken Koontz’s property through an unconstitutional exaction because the condition was not related to the impacts of his project. The intermediate appellate court affirmed.

The Florida Supreme Court reversed, holding there was no taking. The court explained that the Nollan-Dolan test only applied to exactions of real property, where a permit was actually issued imposing the onerous exaction. The court acknowledged a line of cases applying the Nollan-Dolan test beyond real property exactions, but it held that these cases went beyond the U.S. Supreme Court’s decisions. The court also pointed to Monterev v. Del Monte Dunes at Monterev, Ltd., 526 U.S. 687 (1999), and Lingle v.Chevron U.S.A., Inc., 544 U.S. 528 (2005), to support its conclusion that the Nollan-Dollan only applies when the government actually issues the permit that is sought because only then is the owner’s property interest subject to dedication.

Finally, even though the court denied the property owner’s claim, it expressed a public policy concern for other developers and landowners. It worried that “agencies will opt to simply deny permits outright without discussion or negotiation rather than risk the crushing costs of litigation. Property owners will have no opportunity to amend their applications or discuss mitigation options because the regulatory entity will be unwilling to subject itself to potential liability. Land development in certain areas of Florida would come to a standstill. We decline to approve a rule of law that would place Florida land-use regulation in such an unduly restrictive position.” Koontz, 77 So. 3d at 1231.

Consequently, the Florida Supreme Court held there was no taking because (1) no permit was ever issued, (2) the exaction did not demand real property, and (3) public policy precluded expansion

The U.S. Supreme Court Hears Koontz

On October 5, 2012, the U.S. Supreme Court granted certiorari, and it heard oral arguments on January 15, 2013. Koontz asks the Court to establish:
  1. The Nollan-Dolan exactions test applies to exactions other than real property, such as where a permit applicant is required to pay for work; and
  2. The Nollan-Dolan exactions test applies even where a permit is denied because an applicant rejects an exaction.
Koontz argues that the Court does not have to stretch far to make such a ruling, as it has held in other contexts that government may not withhold discretionary benefits on the condition that the beneficiary surrender a constitutional right. Koontz also argues that both of these issues need to be settled by the Court because the law on these issues has developed such a split across the country that courts facing the issue are having to choose a side, necessitating clear guidance from the Court.

The District, on the other hand, argues that the Court does not have jurisdiction because of Koontz only brought state law claims in state courts (not federal claims). Echoing the Florida Supreme Court, the District also argues it did not exact or take anything because it never issued a permit or collected an exaction.

Early on, there were reasons to think that this case would be an important case for planners and land use lawyers to watch. First, the Pacific Legal Foundation, which is representing Koontz, has shown a knack for litigating environmental and property rights cases before the U.S. Supreme Court, having participated in more than half a dozen landmark decisions. Indeed, it argued and won Nollan, and in March of this year, it won Sackett v. EPA, 566 U.S. __ (2012), which gave property owners the right to take EPA to court over a compliance order dealing with wetlands. Second, this case is positioned well as a vehicle for the Court’s property-rights advocates, as it seems to present the review of a clean issue of law, rather than a messy fact-specific or jurisdictional fight. Justices Scalia, Kennedy, and Thomas have shown an interest in the past in the timing of permit conditions. See Lambert v. San Francisco, 529 U.S. 1045, 1048 (2000) (dissenting from denial of certiorari).

Reading the tea leaves of oral arguments at the Supreme Court is always a dangerous business. That said, I and others have made several observations. First, Justice Scalia, who the landowner almost certainly needs to win a majority, seemed critical of whether anything had actually been taken. Second, while a majority of the Justices appeared at least somewhat sympathetic to the landowner’s plight, there was little agreement amongst them in terms of whether there was a constitutional harm and, if so, what the remedy to it should be. Finally, the reach of the unconstitutional conditions doctrine, which Nollan, Dolan, and Lingle indicate is the origin of exactions law, took center stage. This notoriously murky doctrine stands for the proposition that [a]cts generally lawful may become unlawful when done to accomplish an unlawful end, and a constitutional power cannot be used by way of condition to attain an unconstitutional result.” Frost v. R.R. Comm'n of Cal., 271 U.S. 583, 598-99 (1926). The Supreme Court has traditionally struggled with appropriate breadth of this doctrine, and they appear to be struggling with it in this case, as well.

Jacob T. Cremer is an attorney at Bricklemyer Smolker, P.A., in Tampa, Florida. His practice focuses on property rights, environmental, and land use law. He assisted counsel of record before the U.S. Supreme Court for the landowner-petitioners in Stop the Beach Renourishment, Inc. v. Fla. Dep't of Envtl. Prot., 130 S. Ct. 2592 (2010). He co-authored an amicus brief in support of the landowner-petitioner in Koontz and attended oral arguments. Follow the developments on this case and others at his blog, The Florida Land Environment, www.jacobtcremer.com.

Thursday, February 7, 2013

Local Governments in Florida May Condition Land Development Orders on Expert Agency Review

A recent decision out of one of Florida's intermediate appellate courts has clarified some finer points of land use law. In Seminole Tribe of Florida v. Hendry County, - So. 3d -, 2013 WL 238231 (Fla. 2d DCA Jan. 23, 2013), the Tribe challenged a rezoning of over 3,000 acres for a Florida Power & Light power plant. The Tribe had already lost in a certiorari proceeding before the circuit court. In Florida, a land use certiorari proceeding works like an appeal--the logic being that the party has already had a quasi-judicial proceeding to present the case for its permit, request, or development order before a local board . Thus, the Second District Court of Appeal's (2d DCA) review was extremely narrow: it could only determine whether the circuit court afforded procedural due process and applied the correct law.

The 2d DCA, however, did clarify some finer points of Florida land use law. First, it re-emphasized a point that has been made in a number of cases: comprehensive plan challenges must be raised in their own separate lawsuit and not in a certiorari proceeding. The Tribe had argued that the county's land development code had, in essence, incorporated the county's entire comprehensive plan. This, the Tribe argued, meant that it could bring its comprehensive plan challenge in both the certiorari proceeding, as well as in another lawsuit it filed separately. The 2d DCA disagreed, reasoning that chapter 163, Florida Statutes, means what it says:
First, the Seminole Tribe argues that the Ordinance was not consistent with the comprehensive plan, in violation of LDC section 1–53–5.4(1) (2010). That section provides as follows: “Only uses which are consistent with the comprehensive plan ... may be approved as a PUD.” The circuit court properly found that section 163.3215, Florida Statutes (2011), would preclude the Seminole Tribe from raising this issue in a petition for writ of certiorari. That section states that it provides the exclusive methods for a party to challenge the consistency of a development order with a comprehensive plan. § 163.3215(1). It provides that an adversely affected party may maintain a de novo action for declaratory or other relief to challenge a development order. § 163.3215(3). The Seminole Tribe filed a separate action under this subsection along with its certiorari petition. Though section 163.3215(4) provides that an adversely affected party may challenge a development order solely by filing a petition for writ of certiorari if the local government has adopted an ordinance establishing various requirements, the parties have not identified and we have been unable to locate all of these requirements in the Hendry County Code. Consequently, the circuit court afforded procedural due process and applied the correct law in refusing to hear the issue of comprehensive plan consistency on certiorari review.
Second, the 2d DCA made clear that a local government can condition a requirement for a development order on an agency's review of that requirement (and its approval). This issue is critical for small and cash-strapped local governments: why should they have to try to analyze a complicated issue like the water consumption of a power plant, when an expert state or federal agency will be doing the same thing at a later time? The 2d DCA confirmed that they do not have to:
The circuit court determined that the County has sufficiently addressed the issue of water use by conditioning the Ordinance on the approval of the South Florida Water Management District (SFWMD). The circuit court concluded that the water usage issues are within the exclusive jurisdiction of the Department of Environmental Protection or its successor, SFWMD. To support this proposition, the court pointed to section 373.217, Florida Statutes (2010), which authorizes the Department of Environmental Protection to provide programs for the issuance of permits for the consumptive use of water; states that the Florida Water Resources Act of 1972, sections 373.203–373.249, Florida Statutes (2010), provides the exclusive authority for requiring permits for the consumptive use of water; and establishes that the Florida Water Resources Act of 1972 supersedes any conflicting law or ordinance. [See also section 373.023, Fla. Stat.]. These statutory sections indicate that the water impact will be addressed by SFWMD and that the County ensured compatibility by conditioning the Ordinance on SFWMD's approval. 
*** 
As to wildlife, the circuit court determined that the County had satisfied its obligation to ensure compatibility by requiring approval by the appropriate state and federal agencies having jurisdiction over water, wetlands, and wildlife habitat. The court pointed to article IV, section 9, of the Florida Constitution, establishing the Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission to exercise the regulatory and executive powers of the state with respect to wild animal life and fresh water aquatic life. Establishing this condition was an appropriate way to ensure compatibility regarding wildlife. See LDC § 1–53–5.3(c). The circuit court afforded due process and applied the correct law as to these issues of compatibility.
There are some interesting issues in the background of this case concerning Florida's Power Plant Siting Act (PPSA), which is basically a one-stop permitting shop for power plants. But they did not come out much in this opinion. The Tribe has another appeal pending that raises interesting issues concerning how the PPSA  interplays with Florida's Community Planning Act. We'll just have to wait to see what the 2d DCA does with that case. In the meantime, if you're interested in learning more about the PPSA, the definitive article on it was just published last October. The author, Douglas Roberts, was my former colleague and one of the attorneys representing Florida Power & Light in this case. (In full disclosure, I helped represent Florida Power & Light in this case and the appeal.)


Wednesday, February 6, 2013

Ripeness for Takings Challenges in Florida Just Got Trickier

As if takings law weren't convoluted enough, it looks like a split has developed within Florida intermediate appellate courts over when takings challenges are ripe for review. For non-takings-geeks, that means that Florida courts now disagree about when you can ask a court to consider whether the government has taken your property without just compensation.

In Alachua Land Investors, LLC v. Gainesville, - So. 3d -, 2013 WL 363376 (Fla. 1st DCA Jan. 31, 2013), the 1st DCA put up a huge roadblock for plaintiffs pursuing takings claims. A developer made one plat application that was rejected by the local government, which apparently made some overtures that it might possibly, one day, you know, maybe consider other development proposals. Instead of negotiating further with the government, the developer sued for a taking.

The trial court held that the claim was not ripe for litigation, and the 1st DCA agreed. The court explained that the developer needed to prove: "(1) the regulation denies substantially all economically beneficial or productive use of the land; (2) alternative uses were applied for and conclusively denied by the regulatory body; and (3) at least one meaningful application has been filed under the existing regulations."

The government argued that the developer's application was not meaningful, and that the government's decision was not final. As for the meaningfulness of the application, the court strangely says that because the developer didn't explore the full range of government discretion, the application wasn't meaningful:
Given the existing zoning regulations, ALI's request to construct a sewer pipe through the conservation area and across the creek was bound to fail. The petition was not a meaningful application, for it denied the City an opportunity to exercise its full discretion in determining how ALI can implement the development plans for Phases Two and Three. See Palazzolo, 533 U.S. at 620–21. ALI premised its proposal on a prohibited use in the conservation area that was self imposed as a result of the negotiated settlement. The City is simply enforcing the terms of the landowner's settlement agreement, which were incorporated into the Master Plan and the zoning regulations. 
ALI took an inflexible, all-or-nothing approach in seeking approval of Petition 76SUB. The plat application presented no alternative design plan, nor did ALI seek to revise the application after the City's vote. “Land use planning is not an all-or-nothing proposition.” MacDonald, Sommer & Frates, 477 U.S. at 347 (noting that “[a] governmental entity is not required to permit a landowner to develop property to [the] full extent he might desire or be charged with an unconstitutional taking of the property”). Good faith and reasonableness are integral elements of any meaningful application. See Good v. United States, 39 Fed. Cl. 81, 102–03 (Ct.Fed.Cl.1997) (“By requiring developers to make a good faith effort to satisfy permitting agency concerns after an initial denial, ripeness doctrine reflects the reality that land development often involves a process of negotiation between the permitting agency and developer.”), aff'd, 189 F.3d at 1355. Rather than address any alternatives for achieving its ultimate residential development goals, ALI focuses unreasonably on the proposal to run the sewer pipe through the conservation area and across the creek. In construing the issue so narrowly, ALI effectively removes any discretion on the part of the City to consider other options for ALI to complete Phases Two and Three. The trial court found that the parties originally had discussed viable alternatives to running the sewer line through the conservation area, and that such alternatives were available, even if more costly. After the City's denial of the petition, however, ALI immediately filed suit rather than propose any revisions or seek any changes.
The 1st DCA then goes on to question the finality of the denial because the government might approve the plat the next time around:
Similarly, the City Commission's vote denying Petition 76SUB lacked the requisite finality to render this case ripe for review on the merits. As in Tinnerman, the question of what the City Commission would have done if ALI had proposed any alternatives remains open. At the City Commission hearing, a representative of the City (Ms. Massey) opined that what ALI was proposing in its plat design application is inconsistent with the land uses allowed in the Master Plan. To change it, ALI would have to submit a plan development  amendment. Commissioner Lowe voiced similar concerns about whether the application is consistent with the Master Plan. Commissioner Donovan opined that ALI seemed to have developmental rights if it “would only develop a plan” acknowledging certain requirements. Donovan agreed with other commissioners to “give [ALI] a second chance.” Commissioner Henry expressed discomfort with completely voting down the plat application, suggesting instead that ALI consult with the City to determine what was needed “to make this work” and allow ALI to come back with a feasible plan. Commissioner Bryant urged ALI to continue working with the City in seeking to resolve the land-use issues. Mayor Hanrahan addressed possible redesign options upon the City's disapproval of Petition 76SUB, so that ALI could return to the City for reconsideration without the usual, prolonged delays 
The clear message of a majority of the City's ultimate land-use decision-makers was that they wanted to reach a  mutually agreeable resolution of ALI's ultimate development plans. It is also noteworthy that the developers of the Blues Creek subdivision have enjoyed a successful, long-term working relationship with the City. See Lost Tree Vill. Corp., 838 So.2d at 573 (recognizing the relevance of the working relationship between the landowner and the governmental entity in determining whether a decision is final and whether the submission of an additional application would be futile). Historically, the City Commission had granted final approval of every other Blues Creek plat approval petition (regarding other units and phases) that ALI submitted. Given these circumstances, the record belies ALI's argument that the City's vote on Petition 76SUB was a definitive, final decision on a meaningful application for purposes of the ripeness inquiry. See Tinnerman, 641 So.2d at 525 (“[T]he ripeness requirement of a final decision requires more than procedural finality because it includes an opportunity for government to change its mind.”). Additionally, where its options were not fully exercised, ALI has not demonstrated that the futility doctrine applies here. See McKee v. Tallahassee, 664 So.2d 333, 334 (Fla. 1st DCA 1995) (concluding that the city's decision was not “final,” the futility doctrine did not apply, and the “taking” claim was not ripe, where the municipal board denied a variance from development restrictions, but city officials repeatedly assured the landowner that a properly drafted, meaningful application for a variance, with a required development plan, would receive a positive review).
Compare that to the clear language in Koontz v. St. Johns River Water Mgmt. Dist., 720 So. 2d 560, 562 (Fla. 5th DCA 1998) [aside - yep, you guessed it, this was a precursor to the Koontz case being considered right now by the U.S. Supreme Court].
It is St. Johns' position that since there was a chance that a modified application might be approved, there was no final agency action. To be more precise, the District argued that since it had indicated that it would have granted the application if the owner had agreed to the off-site improvements, the owner should be required to make additional filings making other concessions until the District finally approves the permits before the owner is permitted to pursue a regulatory taking. We disagree. Koontz made a specific application to the District for permits that would permit him to develop a fraction of his property. His position, in effect, was that the application he filed and the concessions he was willing to make to the District in order for it to issue the permits (his giving up over two-thirds of his property to the District) was all that he could do and still retain an economic use of his property. The District turned him down. It made a final decision on the only application before it. One of the members of the District observed: “If they got a lawyer they ought to get him, get on with him.” There is no requirement that an owner turned down in his effort to develop his property must continue to submit offers until the governing body finally approves one before he can go to court. n.2 If the governing body finally turns down an application and the owner does not desire to make any further concessions in order to possibly obtain an approval, the issue is ripe. The owner in this case drew a line in the sand and told the District: “I can go no further.” Whether the owner can now convince the court that there has, in fact, been a taking is the issue properly before the trial court. 
n.2. But in Williamson, the applicant had not applied, and been turned down, for a variance that could have substantially affected the use of his property. Here, there was no other procedure left to the applicant to realize the economic feasibility of his project. The owner's only hope was for the District to change its mind on its conditions for approving the grant of the permits. St. Johns suggests that Koontz should have been required to submit another application offering to give the District two-thirds of his property and do the off-site improvements to one of the parcels owned by the District. And if the District still rejected the plan, he should have been required to submit yet another application agreeing to give two thirds of his property and possibly do the off-site improvements on the District's property but perhaps capping the cost to a particular amount. Such a requirement would eventually discourage the owner so that he might just go away. Here, the District turned down the owner's final submission. The issue is ripe.
The Koontz position seems much sounder: just let the landowner into court, where she can try to prove up her case, and the court can balance whether anything was taken. This court really seems to be conflating the merits of the development application--and the case--with ripeness. They're related, but not in the way this court describes. Note that I'm not saying that the developer should win here. The facts aren't especially good for the developer, since it seems that the developer may have negotiated away its rights to develop in the way it wanted to. But that doesn't change the fact that it's now unclear what is a final, meaningful application to develop land in Florida.

In Florida, where decisions of District Courts of Appeal conflict, the Florida Supreme Court has discretionary jurisdiction to hear the case. The Florida Supreme Court, however, only accepts a very small percentage of these cases. Consequently, property owners in the 1st DCA's jurisdiction (roughly the North Florida, including the Panhandle) may be stuck with a decision that frustrates their efforts to get into court on takings claims.



Tuesday, February 5, 2013

Florida Courts Must Defer to Administrative Agencies' Interpretation of Their Own Rules

In Florida, as in other states and in federal law, courts must give deference to an administrative agency's interpretation of its own rules. I've found that the average citizen usually finds this odd. Why should we allow an agency making a determination on a permit, entitlement, or other benefit to interpret its own rules? The short answer is administrative law is about efficiency, and not always about fairness.

In any case, the 2d DCA recently reinforced this principle in Duke's Steakhouse Ft. Myers, Inc. v. G5 Properties, LLC, - So. 3d -, 2013 WL 191922 (Fla. 2d DCA Jan. 18, 2013). Duke's challenged an order of the South Florida Water Management District approving an environmental resource permit (ERP). The administrative law judge (ALJ) recommended that the agency deny the permit. The District, however, issued a final order approving the ERP, rejecting the ALJ's interpretation of the District's rules:
[The District's] board did not reweigh the evidence or modify the ALJ's findings of fact. Rather, it rejected the ALJ's interpretation of the applicable Florida Administrative Code—specifically, the ALJ's conclusion of law that G5 did not meet BOR section 5.2.1(a) water quality requirements. Section 120.57(1)(l ) provides that an agency may reject or modify the ALJ's conclusions of law and interpretation of administrative rules, so long as its determination is as or more reasonable than those of the ALJ. Beyond peradventure, an agency bears the primary responsibility to interpret statutes and rules within its regulatory expertise and jurisdiction. See, e.g., Pub. Emps. Relations Comm'n v. Dade Cnty. Police Benevolent Ass'n, 467 So.2d 987, 989 (Fla.1985). An agency's interpretation of such statutes and rules does not have to be the only reasonable interpretation—only a permissible one, see, e.g., Suddath Van Lines, Inc. v. Dep't of Envtl. Prot., 668 So.2d 209, 212 (Fla. 1st DCA 1996), and should not be overturned unless clearly erroneous. See, e.g., Collier County Bd. of County Comm'rs v. Fish & Wildlife Conservation Comm'n, 993 So.2d 69, 72 (Fla. 2d DCA 2008).
The 2d DCA concluded that the District's interpretation of its rules were as or more reasonable than the ALJ's  interpretation. Thus, it affirmed the District final order granting the permit.

Wednesday, January 30, 2013

Raisins Takings Case at the U.S. Supreme Court: When Can You Defend Against a Government Enforcement Action with the Takings Clause?

Lest my readers think property rights are boring, Overlawyered has compared one of this term's takings cases to ... guerrilla warefare! Yep, this is the raisins case, Horne v. U.S. Department of Agriculture, No. 12-236 (cert. granted Nov. 20, 2012), which is to consider whether a New Deal agricultural statute takes property of raisin growers without compensation. Think of the case as basically answering this question: if the government takes you to court because you failed to pay something it required, can you defend against the government by arguing it is attempting to take your property without compensation?

The property owners' summary is excerpted below:
I. The panel erred in holding that it lacked jurisdiction to consider petitioners’ defense under the Takings Clause. That claim is immediately ripe for two independent reasons.  
A. First, under Apfel, a party may challenge a governmental demand for a cash transfer without going through the repetitive steps of paying a fine and then going to the Court of Federal Claims to get the same sum back in the form of compensation for the taking.Second, ripeness bars a lawsuit only in cases where the party seeks anticipatory relief against government action that has not yet taken place. It does not apply when a party seeks to interpose a constitutional defense to an enforcement action brought by the government at the time and in the forum of the government’s own choosing. 
B. Recent cases applying a specialized “ripeness”doctrine to takings claims confuse ripeness with equitable principles regarding the propriety of is-suing an injunction. A review of the text, structure,and historical interpretation of the Takings Clause confirms that a party can obtain affirmative injunctive relief under the Clause or raise the Clause as a defense. The historical record shows that, from the earliest cases, a party could raise the Takings Clause as a defense to government enforcement action. During the Nineteenth Century, courts (including this Court) held that affirmative injunctive relief was also available under the Clause where a party lacked a“reasonable, certain, and adequate” monetary remedy. This rule paralleled the standard for obtaining affirmative injunctive relief under Ex parte Young, 209 U.S. 123 (1908). The availability of affirmative injunctive relief did not limit the ability of parties to raise the Takings Clause as a defense. Nor was this rule ever characterized as an aspect of “ripeness” or“subject-matter jurisdiction” doctrine. It was viewed as the standard for obtaining injunctive relief under the Clause — what would now be described as “choice of remedies.” Once the background legal rule is properly viewed (as an equitable principle regarding the availability of affirmative injunctive relief), it be-comes clear that the panel’s decision that it lacked jurisdiction because petitioners’ takings claim is “unripe” was erroneous. 
II. The review procedures of the AMAA withdraw the Tucker Act. The panel’s holding that those procedures were inapplicable because petitioners challenged the USDA order in their “capacity as producers” rather than “handlers” misunderstands the statutory scheme and contradicts the litigating posture of the government in this very case.The decision below should be reversed and the case remanded for consideration of petitioners’ takings defense on the merits.
Four amicus briefs have been filed in support of the property owners by the Cato Institute, the U.S. Chamber of Commerce, the State of Texas, and a group of constitutional law professors. For those interested, a minor California newspaper has an article with some background. Robert Thomas also has some good thoughts on each of the briefs over at his blog.

We'll see the government's brief and supporting amici's briefs soon. Oral arguments in the case have been set for March 20, 2013.

Tuesday, January 29, 2013

In Forest Roads Case, Path for U.S. Supreme Court Still Unclear as Supplemental Briefs Arrive

As the supplemental briefs arrive in the forest roads case (consolidated: Decker v. NEDC, No. 11-338, and Georgia-Pacific West, Inc. v. NEDC, No. 11-347), it remains unclear what the U.S. Supreme Court will do with the case. My readers will recall that what was shaping up to be a win for the forestry community (and the environment) was thrown into disarray when EPA surprised everyone by issuing a new rule on the eve of the U.S. Supreme Court's consideration of the old rule.

The Justices were not happy with this last minute change, and so they requested supplemental briefing after oral argument. The Pacific Legal Foundation blog has fair summaries of the supplemental briefs:
The petitioners (timber companies): The petitioners urge the Court to issue a substantive opinion resolving the “point source” and “industrial activity” questions, and reversing the Ninth Circuit. The case is not moot, they argue, because the new rule did not change the law; rather, it confirmed the position they have advanced from the beginning, which is that EPA’s stormwater regulations exempt logging road runoff from NPDES permitting. They contend that EPA’s authority to exempt logging roads is a live issue that should be resolved. They also explain that resolving the question of EPA’s authority to adopt the exemption will cut off new challenges to the revised rule, and therefore spare the courts from having to litigateDecker all over again. At the very least, say the petitioners, the Court should vacate the Ninth Circuit’s judgment and remand for reconsideration in light of EPA’s new rule. 
The respondent (Northwest Environmental Defense Center): NEDC argues that the new rule does not foreclose its claims against the petitioners, and that the Court should allow lower courts to consider those claims in light of EPA’s new rule in the first instance. NEDC thus asks the Court to dismiss the case as improvidently granted, and remand so the group can continue to press its claims below. NEDC also asks the Court to affirm any aspect of the Ninth Circuit’s opinion that the Court chooses to address. 
United States (by invitation of the Court): The federal government argues that the case was rendered moot by EPA’s new rule because the rule confirms that the timber companies will not have to obtain NPDES permits. This would be so even if the Supreme Court were to uphold the Ninth Circuit’s opinion, which was issued while the old regulatory framework was in place. The government believes the Court should vacate the Ninth Circuit’s judgment, and remand with instructions to dismiss NEDC’s complaint. An alternative avenue would be to vacate the Court of Appeals’ judgment and remand to allow that court to address the effect of the revised rule.
Lyle Dennison at SCOTUSblog summarized:
Lawyers on all sides of the dispute over the federal government’s role — or lack of it — in monitoring the drainage of storm water across logging roads have offered the Supreme Court a range of ideas on what to do with the case, now that it has been argued and new government rules are in place. There was agreement on only one thing: the Court might consider, perhaps as a backup choice, sending the case back to the Ninth Circuit Court for a new review. That is the simplest option among an array of choices laid out in a new round of briefs in two consolidated cases argued seven weeks ago.
I agree with Lyle's hint that if there is an easy way out for the Supreme Court to take, it will find it. As the National Alliance of Forest Landowners has mentioned, the real solution here is congressional action.

Tuesday, January 22, 2013

Florida's 4th DCA Explains that Attorney's Fees and Costs for Work Leading up to Successful Takings Suit is Recoverable

This is a simple case, but a good one to be aware of. 

In Board of Supervisors of St. John's Water Control District v. Florida Department of Transportation,  - So. 3d -, 2012 WL 5933012 (Fla. 4th DCA Nov. 28, 2012), the parties agreed that the District was entitled to attorney's fees and costs because it was successful in an inverse condemnation lawsuit. The circuit court ruled, however, that the District was not entitled to its fees and costs in a prior lawsuit, in which it was determined that the District actually owned the property in question. The appellate court reversed, explaining: 
Under Florida law, a property owner awarded fees under the lodestar method is entitled to its reasonable attorneys' fees for all work relating to a condemnation suit, including work performed before the date suit is actually filed. See Volusia Cnty. v. Pickens, 435 So. 2d 247, 248 (Fla. 5th DCA 1983) (an inverse condemnation plaintiff was "entitled to recover a reasonable amount for all costs and attorney's fees reasonably and necessarily expended in connection with the investigation, research, preparation and presentation of the case" despite the defendant's argument that the plaintiff's entitlement to attorney's fees was limited to a certain date range); State Dep't of Trans. v. Grice Elecs., Inc., 356 So. 2d 7, 7 (Fla. 1st DCA 1977) (the trial court did not err when it awarded "compensation to appellee's attorneys for work performed before suit was filed but after condemnation was imminent").
That is, it takes work to get to the point of filing a taking claim, and a prevailing landowner should be compensated for that. Makes sense to me.

Sunday, January 20, 2013

Two Florida Courts Apply Penn Central Taking Test with Reasonable Results


In Florida, as in many other places, courts have had trouble applying the Penn Central takings test. Some folks argue that this case is so muddled and unworkable that it was not only a bad takings case, but also one of the worst cases the U.S. Supreme Court ever decided. Recently, however, two courts applied the test, coming to (surpisingly) reasonable results in opinions issued on the same day. 

Galleon Bay Corp. v. Bd. of Cnty. Comm'rs of Monroe Cnty.

Galleon Bay Corp. v. Board of County Commissioners of Monroe County, - So. 3d, 2012 WL 6027768 (3d DCA Dec. 5, 2012), is one of a number of long-running takings disputes in the Florida Keys. The appellate court started by explaining the Penn Central test:
In addressing whether a "taking" has occurred, the United States Supreme "Court's decisions have identified several factors that have particular significance. The economic impact of the regulation on the claimant and, particularly, the extent to which the regulation has interfered with distinct investment-backed expectations are, of course, relevant considerations." Penn Cent. Transp. Co. v. City of New York, 438 U.S. 104, 124 (1978) (emphasis added). The Supreme Court has also "frequently observed that whether a particular restriction will be rendered invalid by the government's failure to pay for any losses proximately caused by it depends largely `upon the particular circumstances [in that] case.'" Id. (citation omitted). Furthermore, the United States Supreme Court has also found "categorical treatment appropriate . . . where regulation denies all economically beneficial or productive use of land." Lucas v. So. Carolina Coastal Council, 505 U.S. 1003, 1015 (1992). Moreover, the Court has stated "on numerous occasions [that] the Fifth Amendment is violated when land-use regulation `does not substantially advance legitimate state interests or denies an owner economically viable use of his land.'" Id. at 1016 (citation omitted) (emphasis in original).
Robert Thomas has blogged a few thoughts about this case, pointing out that this case is a good example of how subjective these Penn Central determinations can be. Ultimately, the appellate court held that the trial court did not find a taking because it had incorrectly applied both Penn Central and Lucas. Further, it held that the landowner had "been deprived of all or substantially all of the economically viable use of its property." 

Although the appellate court held a taking had occurred and remanded the case to hold a trial on compensation, it is not yet final because the parties are awaiting a ruling on a motion for rehearing en banc.

Scott v. Galaxy Fireworks, Inc.

On the other hand, in Scott v. Galaxy Fireworks, Inc., - So. 3d -, 2012 WL 6028835 (2d DCA Dec. 5, 2012), the trial court found a taking that the appellate court reversed. In 1998, the governor of Florida entered an executive order that banned the sales, use, or discharge of fireworks for approximately two weeks. The order prohibited sales during the Fourth of July, during Florida's worst drought and fire season in recent history. The retailer showed that it realized approximately seventy percent of its profits during that time period and that it takes months of preparation to do so.

The trial court found a compensable taking, but the the appellate court reversed, holding that under Penn Central, there was no taking:
In addressing the owners' argument, the Supreme Court set forth the following three factors to be considered in determining whether there has been a compensable taking: (1) "[t]he economic impact of the regulation on the claimant," (2) "the character of the governmental action," and (3) "the extent to which the regulation has interfered with distinct investment-backed expectations." Penn Central, 438 U.S. at 124. Applying these three factors to the instant case, we conclude that the executive order here did not amount to a compensable taking.
***
Here, the sale of fireworks is highly regulated due to the potential danger resulting from their discharge. Appellees voluntarily invested in their inventories knowing that the regulation of the sale and use of such was subject to change from time to time and from locality to locality. The temporary limitation on the sale of the fireworks under these facts does not rise to such an interference with investment-backed expectations as to constitute a compensable taking.
Translation: stay out of highly regulated industries if you want to protect your investment! The court's language equating the government's police powers with the "character of the governmental action" concerns me some. I lived in Florida during that time, and with a family in the forestry business, I was able to see first-hand the devastation that the fires wrought in the state. There was certainly a state of emergency, which should be the important point - not necessarily that the state acted within its police powers. Later courts could easily use it out of context. But at least here, the result seems reasonable. The case is not yet final because the parties have just finished briefing Galaxy's motion for rehearing en banc.

Saturday, January 19, 2013

The Unintended Consequences of Land Use Controls

There's a good op-ed piece in the Wall Street Journal this week that would be funny--if it weren't so maddeningly true. Roger Kimball writes about his struggles with local land use agencies and FEMA in trying to rebuild after Hurricane Sandy:
In "The Road to Serfdom," Friedrich Hayek noted that "the power which a multiple millionaire, who may be my neighbor and perhaps my employer, has over me is very much less than that which the smallest functionnaire possesses who wields the coercive power of the state on whose discretion it depends whether and how I am to be allowed to live or to work." 
And how. But what makes the phenomenon so insidious is that many of the functionaries are as friendly as can be. It's just that they're cogs in a machine whose overriding purpose is not service but self-perpetuation and control. 
It is, as Alexis de Tocqueville saw, a recipe for a form of despotism peculiar to modern democracies. It does this, wrote Tocqueville, by enforcing "a network of small, complicated, painstaking, uniform rules" that reduces citizens "to being nothing more than a herd of timid and industrious animals of which the government is the shepherd." The sobering thought is that we're all complicit in that infantilization. After all, we keep voting for the politicians who put this leviathan in place.
My friends who read Austrian economics are probably thinking Kimball sounds a lot like Frédéric Bastiat:
In the economic sphere an act, a habit, an institution, a law produces not only one effect, but a series of effects. Of these effects, the first alone is immediate; it appears simultaneously with its cause; it is seen. The other effects emerge only subsequently; they are not seen; we are fortunate if we foresee them.
Why should it be so tough to rebuild after a natural disaster? The seen and the unseen, indeed.